This movie is one of those rare ones that only received one Oscar nomination. Usually, Oscar nominations are like disasters and come in (at least) two or three, but not in this case. And after watching Rustin, I concur that The Academy got it right in this instance. Colman Domingo shines and leads this film from mediocrity into “it’s pretty good”, and it all stands and falls on his performance. This movie is the typical example of a decently average biography that shines due to its lead performer.
I might have enjoyed Rustin a bit more than others because I had never heard of him until I watched this film. I, of course, knew about the march on Washington and MLK but had no idea about “some Bayard Rustin”, and I think I am not alone, hence this movie. I liked how it shows that actual activism takes many people to get together, organize, plan and organize one more time when things change for everything to go well. And in that instance, this movie won me over easily because it showcases these helpers (not just Rustin) and how much time and effort went into everything. It’s easy to send a tweet with a hashtag; it’s fairly easy to donate money (given you can afford it), but to donate your time and energy for next to nothing… that’s impressive.
I have seen Colman Domingo in Euphoria (2019 – ?), so I knew he was a talented actor. But in Rustin, he gives us something new. I loved his energetic portrait, where you understand his character within minutes, specifically how he can be both correct and still a bit of a dick. Colman portrays him in such a way you recognise people you know in him. I believe we all have met at least one Rustin in our life – this guy is energetic, talks a big game, is obviously charming and clever, and some people adore him. And he makes it harder to adore him because of his erratic behaviour at times. But because of Colman Domingo’s performance, you are hanging on his every word, every scene he is in, you are so in it because of his powerful performance. He transcends the movie, as his character almost belongs in a different, much better film.
Here was my main issue with Rustin, and I am not the first person to mention this – besides Colman, this movie is just an average biopic. When I said: “The Academy got it right this time”, I could have easily written, “This film needs to step up to be on Colman’s level.” It is not like this movie is bad by any means, but for a biopic about someone so important, vivid and energetic, the movie is… well, the opposite of that. You will notice, especially in the scenes with no Colman Domingo, how generic this movie feels and looks. We still have many great performers here (from Chris Rock to Da’Vine Joy Randolph), so the issue isn’t there; it’s more about the execution. The film looks like many other Netflix movies (because it is one), but that shouldn’t matter as they produced some quality material in the past (Roma (2018), anyone?), so there is no excuse for this film to look so… generic.
Another tiny issue is, as I mentioned above, this is as standard of a biopic as they come. We are introduced to our protagonist; he shows why he is so good but has some character flaws. We see him winning at first, then losing, only for him to ultimately win in the end. I understand the mentality of “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it”, but again, for such a unique personality as Bayard Rustin seemed to have been, it is contra productive to produce a generic, run-of-a-mill movie that captures you enough when you watch it but will struggle to recall in one week.
Let me make this clear; my rating you will see soon is inflated by one extra star only for Colman’s performance, as he is the definition of a leading man. From now on, if he leads, I will follow because this guy can command a screen and uplift a film. But this movie is ultimately just ok. The historical importance is as undeniable as Colman’s brilliant performance. It’s just too bad the rest of the film never catches up with him. Rustin is a weird one because I have not seen The Academy get a movie “right” like this in a long time – let’s honour this leading man, but we can forget about literally everything else because it is just fine.
Overall, Rustin is a fairly short movie about one under-sung hero of the Civil Rights Movement and what it took to organise and get it done. It features many talented people, but you will remember one name above them all – Colman Domingo. His performance will never leave you cold, and every time he is on the screen, you forgive the averageness of everything else that’s happening around him. I would cautiously recommend Rustin, specifically for its historical significance and Colman’s superb performance. As for the rest of the film… I can say it is a movie for sure.
That’s all for this one! Did you see it? What did you think about it? Let me know!
Until next time,
Luke
