If there are two genres I love, it’s action and sci-fi. By that logic, if you combine them and do them well, I tend to enjoy myself and have a blast with those films. So when I heard of this movie, I was hopeful going into it because I remember seeing it when it landed on Amazon Prime, but I never clicked on it as I’ve always had “better things” to watch. Well, one day, I finally pulled the trigger and pressed play on this movie, and I will say there are some decent ideas here. But it’s packaged, paced and told in such a way that nothing will ever surprise you.
The idea that humanity semi-masters the time travel and must go back in time for people to help them win a war against aliens is fascinating. There were sequences that were also done well (like the first landing in the future and the 20 minutes that followed). And there are some fun cast members this movie wastes. But unfortunately, everything else failed for me.
Let’s start with the idea – it’s solid. Sure, you need to accept a lot of stuff for it to make sense (like how they only semi-mastered the time travel, so they can’t go back as much as they want etc.), but it was intriguing. However, as the movie progresses and takes shape, I wondered what it would look like in the hands of someone more capable. I like Chris McKay, but I am not sure this was the best material for him to tackle because this story is so ambitious, and the ultimate message is pretty important, but if you don’t know how to sell it to us, it will sound cheesy and cheap. And that’s what ultimately happened with The Tomorrow War. Without going into spoilers, everything that happens and gets revealed in the third act is questionable, and with that, this movie found itself in this weird category where you may agree with its themes and message, but you don’t like how everything gets told. Well, at least I found myself there.
The cast is another thing. I don’t know what happened to Chris Pratt, but his charisma no longer works for me, and it’s been like this since about 2016. I used to love him, mainly as a comedian, and now, he is trying to do this almost Ryan Reynolds thing, and the thing is, he isn’t Ryan. And by having him try it, it proves that Ryan isn’t just being himself, but there is more to his performances, and he gets short-shrift by many fans. I hope Chris can turn this around and maybe take a step back, do a comedy or two and maybe try again…? J.K. Simmons is here and plays this absentee dad to Pratt, but for most of the movie, he isn’t there at all. When the movie needs him, he’s got some moments that should make us care about him, but I didn’t, mainly because of how this movie brought him back in the third half when he was in there for about two minutes before that.
Who I thought did an underrated job and might be one of our most underrated actresses (especially comedy-wise) is Mary Lynn Rajskub. In everything I have seen her in throughout the past several years, I thought she was sneakily one of, if not the best thing about that movie, TV show or scene. In The Tomorrow War, her character doesn’t get to do much, but she makes her scenes memorable; she is funny, and it never feels cringey. For example, we have the brilliant Sam Richardson here also playing this comedic relief for the most part, and his character didn’t work for me at all. I love Sam; I have seen him in many other films and shows, so I know it wasn’t him, but there was something about his character that never made him funny to me and, for the majority of this movie, he was supposed to the main comedic relief of this film.
But even that wasn’t my main issue with this movie. My biggest problem was how convenient everything was when the movie needed to move the story along. Again, without going into major spoilers, I will simply say this – Chris Pratt’s character is a teacher before this future war starts. And we get introduced to this one, a very unique student who is passionate about volcanoes. When I tell you this will be important later, I won’t blame you for not believing me. But it is, and I was kinda mad that it was that important and how they based the entire third act on this random piece of knowledge. Sure, many movies have clutches to move forward, but this clutch felt the “clutchiest” I have seen in ages.
What also doesn’t help anything is the runtime of almost 140 minutes. Yes, a lot of stuff happens in this film, but also, there are definitely sequences that could have been cut down a bit, and ultimately, if you manage to get it to around 110 minutes, I think it would have flown much better. The pacing felt very awkward, again, mainly in the third act.
This movie also wants to have a big reveal in the future (technically two reveals), but… The first one is obvious, and the second is a bit less obvious but almost given, accounting for what we have learned from our exposition dump about the future before they go into it. It always makes me laugh how movies try to do these “shocking” reveals only for most of the audience to react like: “…Okay? Wasn’t that given?”
And ultimately, that’s how I would sum up this movie. It’s not bad by any means; I even contemplated giving it a middle-of-the-road, average rating. But then, I started to think about my rating, how much I have actually enjoyed this movie and whether I will remember much about it a couple of weeks or months down the line. I realised I won’t remember much about it because everything is just… okay-ish. And the more movies I watch, the more I forget these movies that don’t stand out in any way, shape or form, mainly if there isn’t at least one excellent or awesome thing to remember. The Tomorrow War has some cool things about it, but they never managed to make those things pay off.
Overall, The Tomorrow War is a great concept, with decent actors and average execution. Unfortunately, the execution becomes below average when the third act happens as there are way too many “Oh come the fuck on now!” situations for me to swallow or ignore. I would, however, love to see it remade by someone who likes to play with big ideas. For example, if you told me that Christopher Nolan or Alex Garland wanted to remake it, I would be the first to say: “Yes, please!” as I would trust both of these directors to take this concept, not changing a thing thematically, and/or narratively and arrive at the destination much smoother than this movie did. And I write this as someone who again agrees with everything this movie says.
That’s all for this one! Did you see it? What did you think about it? Let me know!
Until next time,
Luke