As with countless other shows, I have heard many good things about The Good Place. The only other thing I knew about this show was that there was a twist somewhere that changed the entire show. When I watched it, it wasn’t that hard for me to guess what that twist was because if you know “something” is coming but you don’t know what, you can only guess so many things, especially with this show. The good thing is that even knowing there is a twist doesn’t spoil anything for you because The Good Place is really about the journey, not the destination. And I think that is what will make it a great show to rewatch over and over again.
Before I delve into this show, I want to take a moment and briefly mention the creator of this show, Michael Schur. For some, he might still be pretty unknown, but he is not only behind this show; he also co-created Parks and Recreation (2009 – 2015), Brooklyn Nine-Nine (2013 – 2021, my review here) and wrote some episodes of The Office (2005 – 2013, my review here). Even if he stopped working today, his legacy is undeniable as he has either created or helped to create some of the most hilarious and iconic shows of today, spanning almost three decades. He is a phenomenally talented guy who should be much more known, given his involvement with many A+ projects. And from all I can tell, The Good Place was his baby from the start until the finish and what a show to be responsible for.
This show is one of those rare ones where you might not laugh all the time while watching it. I would even argue that, in the later seasons, there are fewer laughs and more chuckles. But, it never bothered me because I was intrigued by the story and how effortlessly the writers managed to avoid falling into some obvious traps just for the story’s sake. What I mean is, if you rely on philosophy as heavily as The Good Place does and want to explore such ideas as death, the afterlife, what’s fair and through that lens, you take a look at our lives on Earth and the obstacles we face in day to day lives, it would be easy to take some shortcuts. But this show never does that. Every time we seem to have it figured out, and there might be an answer, the goalpost gets moved. And it isn’t until the last season that you see the clear parallels with life and how that goalpost moving isn’t a cheap trick but rather a necessity because it simply mirrors life.
I could talk about the more indisputable themes this show touches on, like how it is much harder to be a good person because in the times we live in, we are forced to choose many “lesser evils”, many times unknowingly (the flower example was spot on). But what I absolutely loved about The Good Place was how this show sticks by its logic and showcases that life and the afterlife are messy and you can’t be happy forever. The idea of “just” being happy, life with no conflict would be no life at all and how eventually, if you are lucky enough to achieve everything you have ever dreamed of, there is a point where life has no meaning because it’s hard to stay motivated with no purpose.
It’s hard not to watch a show like this thinking about whether you are a good person yourself. I will put my cards on the table and say I don’t believe in any God or afterlife; however, I might be wrong. Therefore, like everybody, I occasionally wonder if some sort of afterlife exists and whether it would be as simple as some religions love to claim (“Just be a good person!”), and you will be eternally awarded. The Good Place is clever about everything, where they jokingly judge people, but, in reality, this show is vocal about how people aren’t inherently “good” or “bad”. Furthermore, if you are only good because you expect a reward at the end and therefore all your good deeds aren’t “pure”, are you a good person?
I must mention the cast, as they are excellent. I will split them into three groups. Kristen Bell and Ted Danson are this TV royalty, where you know they will be great no matter what, and both were. Then there is a second group I would call “almost newcomers”, where people get their chance to shine, some for the very first time. Jameela Jamil is the prime example, as this was her first-ever project, and this show put her on the map. William Jackson Harper and Manny Jacinto have been in some shows and movies before, but it was this show that allowed them to flex their acting muscles and showcase what they had, and all three nailed their roles. But, there is a third mini-group for one person only, who should have gotten more praise – D’Arcy Carden.
Before I write why, let me stipulate something – The Good Place is the perfect example of an ensemble show. That is why I won’t be writing much about other characters, as they all have been excellent, but, for me, nobody stood out because they all had their well-earned moments in this show and worked their best in a group setting. But if I truly think about one performer who managed to stand out and made the most out of their role, it’s D’Arcy, aka Janet. Not only did she have to portray several different Janets (The Good, Bad, Neutral, Disco and a few others) throughout the show, but there were episodes where she had to portray other characters. Especially the ninth episode of the third season, simply called Janet(s), showcases how D’Arcy takes the boundaries of her role (remember, she can’t emote much because she is neither a girl nor human) and weaponizes them to her advantage. I think that if there were a poll between The Good Place fans about who their favourite character is, it would be (almost) evenly split between the main four (Kristen, Jameela, William and Manny). But for my money, D’Arcy is the MVP of this show, and I hope to see her in more shows and films.
On top of everything I have mentioned, The Good Place also understands what character growth means without compromising the character’s core. Everybody in this show goes through a believable growth, but they never change what made their character unique in the first place. It’s always great when the show understands the difference between growth and character change. If you watch the last episode, everybody has evolved, but they remained Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani and Jason.
No wonder that when we put all of it together, I ended up loving The Good Place. This show doesn’t rely on a twist; they manage to make that twist almost a joke because of what happens next. There are many quick jokes that you need to pay attention to; otherwise, you miss them, and every episode has one or two laugh-out-loud moments. However, this show wasn’t about the laughs. For me, those were a pleasant bonus. This show managed to talk about some of the biggest ideas without sounding condescending. It managed to discuss our current social and political issues without being too snarky or preachy, and if anything else, acknowledged how hard everything has become today and how easier some people have it, but even with those means to excel, they aren’t good people. It showed us our current system and how it favours some over others, but it always moved forward towards improving it rather than abandoning the entire thing. For a comedy show, it presents you with many big ideas, and it’s only up to you how much you take from it.
Overall, The Good Place is an excellent show that knew what it wanted to say, did it and ended. It didn’t drag on for a bit too long; it knew when to go, and because of that, no episode felt like a filler. Everything made sense within the story; the cast had superb chemistry, and it presented you with some big ideas packaged so well that they were easy to understand. I can see myself rewatching it and getting something new from it every rewatch. I can’t praise or recommend this show enough.
That’s all for this one! Did you see it? What did you think about it? Let me know!
Until next time,
Luke