I am not going to lie; this was the biggest surprise of the 96th Academy Awards for me, as I hadn’t heard much about Nyad before this at all. And when I say at all, I mean I wasn’t aware of Diana Nyad either. This meant I was the perfect audience for this movie, given my lack of knowledge about her and whether she would actually succeed. Yes, given there is a movie made about her, it wasn’t hard to assume she would be successful, but this movie doesn’t focus on that; it is more about what it takes to do something like this and what kind of person you must be.
In that sense, Nyad doesn’t bring anything new because we’ve seen these “how far are you willing to go” stories before. On top of that, we seem to have a new trend of humanizing these extraordinary people and looking at them not as heroes but through more of a critical lens. I don’t think it’s weird to say that Nyad and Whiplash (2014) have many things in common, thematically. Both movies are about extraordinary people willing to go further than most people are, who are so sure of themselves that they come across as abrupt or downright rude. One of the big themes of Nyad is her pushing everyone around to the point of alienation because she has such high standards for herself that she can’t see past herself and how she comes across. And more importantly, this is the only way she believes will help her to achieve her big dream.
When the movie started, I thought I would struggle with it because there was something about it I had to get used to. I don’t know whether it was the characters, how nothing much got established, and we were just thrown into Diana’s world, but I didn’t think I would like this movie. But the more time I spent with Diana and her crew, the more I saw her fail and understood her, and the more I started to root for her. To the point that even if I could predict that she would eventually achieve her goal, I was still rooting for her and was invested in her story, all her losses, her trauma, and everything that led to that one big moment. Annette Bening was great in this role; she wasn’t afraid to be unlikeable and get down and dirty. You could feel her every failure, bruise and chapped lips. Now, was it an Oscar-worthy performance? My preference would be somewhere else (cough, May December (2023, my review here) cough); however, I am not mad at Annette for getting recognition because her performance was challenging, both mentally and physically.
The same goes for Jodie Foster. As with Annette, both belong to these Hollywood legends, it’s hard to argue against. And she has some great moments in this movie, too. I specifically liked how you could tell how complex their relationship was, but you understood that they would always be there for each other at the end. No matter what, she had Diana’s back even though, as the film shows us, it wasn’t always easy. And Foster’s performance was great. Again, my preference would be somewhere different (in her category, Penélope Cruz in Ferrari (2023, my review here) comes to mind), but, as I stated at the beginning of this paragraph, it’s tough to argue against these Hollywood legends.
But as mentioned above, it’s the movie itself that surprised me the most, rather than the fact that two Hollywood giants gave great performances. I thought Nyad did a great job portraying someone on the verge of madness, as they believe they can achieve something so extraordinary that nobody else believes in them. It’s always fascinating to me to watch “based on a true story” events that don’t portray the main individual as this flawless hero; they would rather show them as human. Often irritating assholey human, who’s had it tough. And this is how I like my heroes flawed because I have no issues rooting for someone who isn’t “100% great”, as that just rings false.
The only thing with Nyad that dragged it down was that this film felt a bit disjointed, mainly at the start. I know many have had issues with how this film displayed Diana’s childhood and the trauma that she’s been through, but I am the odd one out and say that aspect didn’t bother me. What also knocks this film down, albeit a tiny bit, is the fact that this is still a pretty standard biopic with all its peaks and valleys. Even I, who had no idea who Diana Nyad was, understood why I watched a movie about her (read: that she achieves her goal). Therefore, this movie is truly about a journey rather than the destination, and once you get through the first 20 minutes or so, the journey is worth it.
Overall, Nyad is a solid inspirational film about one dedicated woman who just didn’t know when to give up. Diana Nyad has managed to do something nobody has done before, and if we take her age into account, it just makes it all the more impressive. I also appreciated the “warts and all” approach by the filmmakers and how they weren’t afraid to show Diana in some unflattering scenes. If you are looking for an inspirational movie that clearly tells you that you are never too old to do anything, you just need to be stubborn as fuck; look no further. Nyad also has two great performances on top of that.
That’s all for this one! Did you see it? What did you think about it? Let me know!
Until next time,
Luke
